《象棋残局大全》中的一局车炮士对车双象质疑

zhaodi

如下图，是《象棋残局大全》第520页 第三节 车炮士对车士象 的例一局
[DhtmlXQ]
[DhtmlXQ_ver]www_dpxq_com[/DhtmlXQ_ver]
[DhtmlXQ_init]500,350[/DhtmlXQ_init]
[DhtmlXQ_title]第三节 车炮士对车士象1[/DhtmlXQ_title]
[DhtmlXQ_event][/DhtmlXQ_event]
[DhtmlXQ_date][/DhtmlXQ_date]
[DhtmlXQ_place][/DhtmlXQ_place]
[DhtmlXQ_round][/DhtmlXQ_round]
[DhtmlXQ_table][/DhtmlXQ_table]
[DhtmlXQ_red][/DhtmlXQ_red]
[DhtmlXQ_redteam][/DhtmlXQ_redteam]
[DhtmlXQ_redrating][/DhtmlXQ_redrating]
[DhtmlXQ_blacktime][/DhtmlXQ_time]
[DhtmlXQ_black][/DhtmlXQ_black]
[DhtmlXQ_blackteam][/DhtmlXQ_blackteam]
[DhtmlXQ_blackrating][/DhtmlXQ_blackrating]
[DhtmlXQ_blacktime][/DhtmlXQ_time]
[DhtmlXQ_result]红胜[/DhtmlXQ_result]
[DhtmlXQ_remark][/DhtmlXQ_remark]
[DhtmlXQ_author]七分半[/DhtmlXQ_author]
[DhtmlXQ_binit]3299993739999999994899999999999946994299409960999999999999999999[/DhtmlXQ_binit]
[DhtmlXQ_movelist]484946473748474832304041306041516040484649424643393843454244454744464749464749594767[/DhtmlXQ_movelist]
[DhtmlXQ_move_0_4_1]47673234[/DhtmlXQ_move_0_4_1]
[DhtmlXQ_comment0]     红方有士，其威力增强，车炮士必然可胜车双象，远比车炮相容易取胜。对其他局势也是如此，车炮士对车双士则更为简易。||||     车炮士对车双象也是古今名题。本局则是其中的一则巧局，胜法别拘一格。[/DhtmlXQ_comment0]
[DhtmlXQ_comment3]！！[/DhtmlXQ_comment3]
[DhtmlXQ_comment11]红方妙着弃士，采用先弃后取之法换得双象，又能逼走黑车，从而获胜。[/DhtmlXQ_comment11]
[DhtmlXQ_comment1_5]威胁士五进四将军，黑方无法解救，必然丢象而负。[/DhtmlXQ_comment1_5]
[DhtmlXQ_type]实战中残局[/DhtmlXQ_type]
[DhtmlXQ_timerule][/DhtmlXQ_timerule]
[DhtmlXQ_endtype][/DhtmlXQ_endtype]
[DhtmlXQ_owner]七分半[/DhtmlXQ_owner]
[DhtmlXQ_firstnum]0[/DhtmlXQ_firstnum]
[DhtmlXQ_gametype][/DhtmlXQ_gametype]
[DhtmlXQ_generator]www.ccbridge.net[/DhtmlXQ_generator]
[/DhtmlXQ]

此局着法大家看出来有什么问题吗？

zhaodi

邢兄说得对，如果第5回合，黑走开中车，将是和棋。

[DhtmlXQ]
[DhtmlXQ_ver]www_dpxq_com[/DhtmlXQ_ver]
[DhtmlXQ_init]500,350[/DhtmlXQ_init]
[DhtmlXQ_binit]3299993739999999994899999999999946994299409960999999999999999999[/DhtmlXQ_binit]
[DhtmlXQ_title]第三节 车炮士对车士象1[/DhtmlXQ_title]
[DhtmlXQ_result]红胜[/DhtmlXQ_result]
[DhtmlXQ_author]七分半[/DhtmlXQ_author]
[DhtmlXQ_movelist]48494647374847483230404130604151604048584042585242485232483832383938[/DhtmlXQ_movelist]
[DhtmlXQ_move_0_4_1]47673234[/DhtmlXQ_move_0_4_1]
[DhtmlXQ_comment0]     红方有士，其威力增强，车炮士必然可胜车双象，远比车炮相容易取胜。对其他局势也是如此，车炮士对车双士则更为简易。||||     车炮士对车双象也是古今名题。本局则是其中的一则巧局，胜法别拘一格。[/DhtmlXQ_comment0]
[DhtmlXQ_comment3]！！[/DhtmlXQ_comment3]
[DhtmlXQ_comment2_11]红方妙着弃士，采用先弃后取之法换得双象，又能逼走黑车，从而获胜。[/DhtmlXQ_comment2_11]
[DhtmlXQ_comment1_5]威胁士五进四将军，黑方无法解救，必然丢象而负。[/DhtmlXQ_comment1_5]
[DhtmlXQ_type]实战中残局[/DhtmlXQ_type]
[DhtmlXQ_owner]七分半[/DhtmlXQ_owner]
[DhtmlXQ_firstnum]0[/DhtmlXQ_firstnum]
[DhtmlXQ_move_0_10_2]484649424643393843454244454744464749464749594767[/DhtmlXQ_move_0_10_2][DhtmlXQ_comment12]||妙。[/DhtmlXQ_comment12][DhtmlXQ_comment17]和棋[/DhtmlXQ_comment17]
[DhtmlXQ_refer]http%3A//www.hgchess.com/%0D%0Ahttp%3A//www.hgchess.com/bbs/forum.php%3Fmod%3Dviewthread%26tid%3D32591%26page%3D1%26extra%3D%23pid230746[/DhtmlXQ_refer]
[DhtmlXQ_generator]www.dpxq.com[/DhtmlXQ_generator]
[/DhtmlXQ]

zhaodi

车炮士必然可胜车双象，这个结论应该是正确的，但并不是轻而易举的就能获得胜利。
如1楼棋图，确实是红胜，可是怎么胜呢？很费周折的取胜着法。

zhaodi

孙立先生发短信，对陈兄的着法提出异议，认为弃士和棋。
[DhtmlXQ]
[DhtmlXQ_ver]www_dpxq_com[/DhtmlXQ_ver]
[DhtmlXQ_init]500,350[/DhtmlXQ_init]
[DhtmlXQ_binit]3299993739999999994899999999999946994299409960999999999999999999[/DhtmlXQ_binit]
[DhtmlXQ_title]第三节 车炮士对车士象1[/DhtmlXQ_title]
[DhtmlXQ_result]红胜[/DhtmlXQ_result]
[DhtmlXQ_author]七分半[/DhtmlXQ_author]
[DhtmlXQ_movelist]48494647374847483230404130604151604048584041515249475828414042204777282277725251[/DhtmlXQ_movelist]
[DhtmlXQ_move_0_4_1]47673234[/DhtmlXQ_move_0_4_1]
[DhtmlXQ_comment0]     红方有士，其威力增强，车炮士必然可胜车双象，远比车炮相容易取胜。对其他局势也是如此，车炮士对车双士则更为简易。||||     车炮士对车双象也是古今名题。本局则是其中的一则巧局，胜法别拘一格。[/DhtmlXQ_comment0]
[DhtmlXQ_comment3]！！[/DhtmlXQ_comment3]
[DhtmlXQ_comment2_11]红方妙着弃士，采用先弃后取之法换得双象，又能逼走黑车，从而获胜。[/DhtmlXQ_comment2_11]
[DhtmlXQ_comment1_5]威胁士五进四将军，黑方无法解救，必然丢象而负。[/DhtmlXQ_comment1_5]
[DhtmlXQ_type]实战中残局[/DhtmlXQ_type]
[DhtmlXQ_owner]七分半[/DhtmlXQ_owner]
[DhtmlXQ_firstnum]0[/DhtmlXQ_firstnum]
[DhtmlXQ_move_0_10_2]484649424643393843454244454744464749464749594767[/DhtmlXQ_move_0_10_2]
[DhtmlXQ_comment3_12]||妙。[/DhtmlXQ_comment3_12]
[DhtmlXQ_comment3_17]和棋[/DhtmlXQ_comment3_17]
[DhtmlXQ_move_0_11_3]4042585242485232483832383938[/DhtmlXQ_move_0_11_3]
[DhtmlXQ_move_11_26_9]26217271[/DhtmlXQ_move_11_26_9]
[DhtmlXQ_move_0_14_7]58484737482839494220414328583730525130605852434151506020[/DhtmlXQ_move_0_14_7][DhtmlXQ_move_0_14_5]58564140563639494224475752514041515041442442444250514243363243533252575251505262[/DhtmlXQ_move_0_14_5]
[DhtmlXQ_move_0_14_4]5857414052514042[/DhtmlXQ_move_0_14_4]
[DhtmlXQ_move_7_18_6]282237774264777222244143245472705251434151504140505170505434404364424342343150603121424321226050[/DhtmlXQ_move_7_18_6]
[DhtmlXQ_move_0_16_8]28214757422039495251404320424342[/DhtmlXQ_move_0_16_8]
[DhtmlXQ_move_0_18_10]525177702002394928224041515041432252434050517050523240430220435332525052[/DhtmlXQ_move_0_18_10]
[DhtmlXQ_move_0_20_11]2226394952514041515041432656727056527020[/DhtmlXQ_move_0_20_11][DhtmlXQ_comment20]和棋[/DhtmlXQ_comment20]
[DhtmlXQ_refer]http%3A//www.hgchess.com/%0D%0Ahttp%3A//www.hgchess.com/bbs/forum.php%3Fmod%3Dviewthread%26tid%3D32591%26extra%3Dpage%253D1[/DhtmlXQ_refer]
[DhtmlXQ_generator]www.dpxq.com[/DhtmlXQ_generator]
[/DhtmlXQ]