三气周瑜 黑胜还是和？

chouzhouyu

[DhtmlXQ]
[DhtmlXQ_ver]www_dpxq_com[/DhtmlXQ_ver]
[DhtmlXQ_init]500,350[/DhtmlXQ_init]
[DhtmlXQ_title]第05局 三气周瑜[/DhtmlXQ_title]
[DhtmlXQ_event][/DhtmlXQ_event]
[DhtmlXQ_date][/DhtmlXQ_date]
[DhtmlXQ_place][/DhtmlXQ_place]
[DhtmlXQ_round][/DhtmlXQ_round]
[DhtmlXQ_table][/DhtmlXQ_table]
[DhtmlXQ_red][/DhtmlXQ_red]
[DhtmlXQ_redteam][/DhtmlXQ_redteam]
[DhtmlXQ_redrating][/DhtmlXQ_redrating]
[DhtmlXQ_blacktime][/DhtmlXQ_time]
[DhtmlXQ_black][/DhtmlXQ_black]
[DhtmlXQ_blackteam][/DhtmlXQ_blackteam]
[DhtmlXQ_blackrating][/DhtmlXQ_blackrating]
[DhtmlXQ_blacktime][/DhtmlXQ_time]
[DhtmlXQ_result]黑胜[/DhtmlXQ_result]
[DhtmlXQ_remark][/DhtmlXQ_remark]
[DhtmlXQ_author][/DhtmlXQ_author]
[DhtmlXQ_binit]8399479939999999848799416266709900714299509999995710990619489999[/DhtmlXQ_binit]
[DhtmlXQ_movelist]8454715283231929232910704151504087807079545700025150405057525040292042205202200280867976666576796564795964544858544406164443022439491626472526368684404184743637747641407616373816183848493940414333598918584858393858483837[/DhtmlXQ_movelist]
[DhtmlXQ_move_0_37_1]626136378606[/DhtmlXQ_move_0_37_1]
[DhtmlXQ_move_0_33_2]4725[/DhtmlXQ_move_0_33_2]
[DhtmlXQ_move_0_33_3]864640506261162639492636464536374725373825475979435379724546721253525040524240304232121961511939463630403231384849395859[/DhtmlXQ_move_0_33_3]
[DhtmlXQ_move_3_49_4]46455040534340304333121961511939453530403332384849395859[/DhtmlXQ_move_3_49_4]
[DhtmlXQ_move_3_47_5]53525040524240304232244245353040324240504252384849395859[/DhtmlXQ_move_3_47_5]
[DhtmlXQ_move_3_47_6]61717242716142475352584849594707615150405242403042323839[/DhtmlXQ_move_3_47_6]
[DhtmlXQ_move_3_47_7]454472025352504052424030423202096151093932223031444539194535584849593839[/DhtmlXQ_move_3_47_7]
[DhtmlXQ_move_7_57_8]443430403231384849395859[/DhtmlXQ_move_7_57_8]
[DhtmlXQ_move_7_49_9]44450201535250405242014142324050[/DhtmlXQ_move_7_49_9]
[DhtmlXQ_move_3_35_10]39491626626126274725273746453738254759794353[/DhtmlXQ_move_3_35_10]
[DhtmlXQ_move_0_33_11]8636162636332636434236376252597939493747[/DhtmlXQ_move_0_33_11]
[DhtmlXQ_move_0_28_12]0616544448588636162636332627443458483343485843332728394959896252898652428646472546162547022042521619342428293339193924343938344429194443380849395848[/DhtmlXQ_move_0_28_12]
[DhtmlXQ_move_12_31_13]8646405044430220626116263949263646453637472537382547597943533848454858484948504061517971534371814333[/DhtmlXQ_move_12_31_13]
[DhtmlXQ_move_0_27_14]6252404164630616864648586362162646762636767758487757022057875955[/DhtmlXQ_move_0_27_14]
[DhtmlXQ_move_14_40_15]59496261494761514131524247455141313042324535[/DhtmlXQ_move_14_40_15]
[DhtmlXQ_move_14_37_16]39385969383936377677585947695949[/DhtmlXQ_move_14_37_16]
[DhtmlXQ_move_14_35_17]464426363938598962614131443489883839584852423637[/DhtmlXQ_move_14_35_17]
[DhtmlXQ_move_14_31_18]6362162662612636868141405251595561605535[/DhtmlXQ_move_14_31_18]
[DhtmlXQ_move_14_30_19]48586362061686810224626141405251595161511626393826368185403085353031[/DhtmlXQ_move_14_30_19]
[DhtmlXQ_move_14_28_20]48585242022486464050424106166463162663622636626124424140[/DhtmlXQ_move_14_28_20]
[DhtmlXQ_move_0_25_21]86464858465606163949162656517970625258685242022442322636513136464729707931216858656424023222792921294647645458484959475729284849[/DhtmlXQ_move_0_25_21]
[DhtmlXQ_move_21_41_22]472568583171404171734151656470407343463643333637[/DhtmlXQ_move_21_41_22]
[DhtmlXQ_move_21_35_23]6564263652420224516168584252363752513747493947485150405064747060746460646163646963435859[/DhtmlXQ_move_21_35_23]
[DhtmlXQ_move_23_37_24]646336375181374781714748493968587177585952515949[/DhtmlXQ_move_23_37_24]
[DhtmlXQ_move_0_24_25]7673864648586252733352424030656406166454162646432636394936374232373843413373545373705352704052514047414630403242403042323040324240304232[/DhtmlXQ_move_0_24_25]
[DhtmlXQ_move_25_50_26]02245150[/DhtmlXQ_move_25_50_26]
[DhtmlXQ_move_25_50_27]58484959304032314757514140503130[/DhtmlXQ_move_25_50_27]
[DhtmlXQ_move_27_52_28]47175150[/DhtmlXQ_move_27_52_28]
[DhtmlXQ_move_25_42_29]3343476543736547022454532442476542246547[/DhtmlXQ_move_25_42_29]
[DhtmlXQ_move_25_41_30]43453313545313195352193932223919223219125251[/DhtmlXQ_move_25_41_30]
[DhtmlXQ_move_25_41_31]32223031[/DhtmlXQ_move_25_41_31]
[DhtmlXQ_move_25_28_32]4041656406166454733354444131444333375242162639492636424131324686373886803848433332424131483833434232314136378040022447253839408037388088584849593949883849433808[/DhtmlXQ_move_25_28_32]
[DhtmlXQ_comment24]原谱着法[/DhtmlXQ_comment24]
[DhtmlXQ_comment33]新招[/DhtmlXQ_comment33]
[DhtmlXQ_comment37]？[/DhtmlXQ_comment37]
[DhtmlXQ_comment55]和。[/DhtmlXQ_comment55]
[DhtmlXQ_comment1_39]和。[/DhtmlXQ_comment1_39]
[DhtmlXQ_comment2_33]新招。[/DhtmlXQ_comment2_33]
[DhtmlXQ_comment3_35]？[/DhtmlXQ_comment3_35]
[DhtmlXQ_comment3_62]黑胜。[/DhtmlXQ_comment3_62]
[DhtmlXQ_comment4_62]黑胜。[/DhtmlXQ_comment4_62]
[DhtmlXQ_comment5_60]黑胜。[/DhtmlXQ_comment5_60]
[DhtmlXQ_comment7_64]黑胜。[/DhtmlXQ_comment7_64]
[DhtmlXQ_comment8_62]黑胜。[/DhtmlXQ_comment8_62]
[DhtmlXQ_comment10_45]下同主变。[/DhtmlXQ_comment10_45]
[DhtmlXQ_comment11_42]黑胜。原谱第二局着法。[/DhtmlXQ_comment11_42]
[DhtmlXQ_comment14_42]黑胜。[/DhtmlXQ_comment14_42]
[DhtmlXQ_comment17_46]黑胜。[/DhtmlXQ_comment17_46]
[DhtmlXQ_comment19_46]和。[/DhtmlXQ_comment19_46]
[DhtmlXQ_comment20_41]红胜。[/DhtmlXQ_comment20_41]
[DhtmlXQ_comment21_56]黑胜。[/DhtmlXQ_comment21_56]
[DhtmlXQ_comment22_52]黑胜。[/DhtmlXQ_comment22_52]
[DhtmlXQ_comment25_24]新变！[/DhtmlXQ_comment25_24]
[DhtmlXQ_comment25_41]！[/DhtmlXQ_comment25_41]
[DhtmlXQ_comment25_57]不变作和！[/DhtmlXQ_comment25_57]
[DhtmlXQ_comment26_50]？[/DhtmlXQ_comment26_50]
[DhtmlXQ_comment26_51]！[/DhtmlXQ_comment26_51]
[DhtmlXQ_comment27_50]？[/DhtmlXQ_comment27_50]
[DhtmlXQ_comment27_57]红胜[/DhtmlXQ_comment27_57]
[DhtmlXQ_comment29_51]亦可和[/DhtmlXQ_comment29_51]
[DhtmlXQ_comment30_41]？[/DhtmlXQ_comment30_41]
[DhtmlXQ_comment30_42]？[/DhtmlXQ_comment30_42]
[DhtmlXQ_comment30_47]正！[/DhtmlXQ_comment30_47]
[DhtmlXQ_comment30_51]这样黑不利！[/DhtmlXQ_comment30_51]
[DhtmlXQ_comment31_41]！？[/DhtmlXQ_comment31_41]
[DhtmlXQ_comment31_42]！[/DhtmlXQ_comment31_42]
[DhtmlXQ_type]实战中残局[/DhtmlXQ_type]
[DhtmlXQ_timerule][/DhtmlXQ_timerule]
[DhtmlXQ_endtype][/DhtmlXQ_endtype]
[DhtmlXQ_owner][/DhtmlXQ_owner]
[DhtmlXQ_firstnum]0[/DhtmlXQ_firstnum]
[DhtmlXQ_gametype][/DhtmlXQ_gametype]
[DhtmlXQ_generator]www.ccbridge.net[/DhtmlXQ_generator]
[/DhtmlXQ]
变化还看不清楚。感觉可和。另论坛 我用不了搜索功能，不知道其他人是否如此。不知道有没有发过此局的变化。

hzsjy

沈注：
此局在“百局象棋谱＂列第５局．原结论是和局．后在“渊深海阔象棋谱＂中对图谱进行了修改．在２０１５年由“成都时代出版社”出的“百局象棋谱”中白宏宽先生言道：“原谱和棋，现代排局家认为是黑胜局．”．而在1999年出的“江湖排局集成”中朱鹤洲与陆曙光棋友认为应是红先黑胜。
另有多本棋谱都以为是红先黑胜。这里就不一一例举了。.
而只有1987年由朱鹤洲蒋权裘望禹诠注的“竹香斋象戏谱”中此局才是和局。但是这与1999年的“江湖排局集成”形成了前后不一致的结果。不知1987年后出的棋书作者有否看到此“竹香斋象戏谱”？或还有其它棋谱还有类似结论是我没有看到。另外重版的“江湖排局集成”中是否对此局作了变动？
其实此局和局结论正确。
1987年的“竹香斋象戏谱”中的着法（来源是网上的动态棋谱，不知真假）：
1. 后车平四  马８进６    2. 车一平七  卒２平３
  3. 车七退六  炮２平８    4. 兵五平四  将６平５
  5. 炮一进七  炮８进９    6. 车四退三  车１进２
  7. 兵四进一  将５平６    8. 车四进五  将６平５
  9. 车七进九  象５退３   10. 车四平九  象３进１
11. 炮一退六  炮８退３   12. 后兵进一  炮８进３
13. 后兵进一  炮８平６   14. 后兵平四  卒５平６
15. 兵四平五  卒１平２   16. 炮一平五  将５平６
17. 兵五进一  象１退３   18. 兵三进一  卒２平３
19. 帅六平五  卒３平４   20. 炮五进一  卒４进１
21. 相五进七  卒４进１   22. 相七退五  炮６平８
23. 兵五平四  卒４平５   24. 炮五退三  卒６平５
25. 帅五进一  将６平５   26. 兵三平四  炮８退９
27. 后兵平五  炮８平９   28. 兵五平六
第１７回合黑改走象１进３更适合摆棋摊。

llllssss

应该是和棋
[DhtmlXQ] [DhtmlXQ_ver]www_dpxq_com[/DhtmlXQ_ver] [DhtmlXQ_init]500,350[/DhtmlXQ_init] [DhtmlXQ_title]三气周瑜[/DhtmlXQ_title] [DhtmlXQ_result]和棋[/DhtmlXQ_result] [DhtmlXQ_binit]8499479939999999839987667099624157999999509942710010990619994899[/DhtmlXQ_binit] [DhtmlXQ_movelist]8454715283231929232910704151504087807079545700025150405057525040292042205202200280867976666576798646485846560616394916265651263662527959515859526564[/DhtmlXQ_movelist] [DhtmlXQ_move_0_25_1]6564795964540616544448588636162636332627443458483343485843332728394959896252898652428646472546162547022042521619342428293339193924343938344429194443380849395848[/DhtmlXQ_move_0_25_1] [DhtmlXQ_move_1_31_2]8646405044430220626116263949263646453637472537382547597943533848454858484948504061517971534371814333[/DhtmlXQ_move_1_31_2] [DhtmlXQ_move_1_28_3]485854440616444302248646405062611626394926364645363747253738254759794353797253525040524240304232244245353040324240504252384849395859[/DhtmlXQ_move_1_28_3] [DhtmlXQ_move_3_47_4]61717242716142475352584849594707615150405242403042323839[/DhtmlXQ_move_3_47_4] [DhtmlXQ_move_3_47_5]454472025352504052424030423202096151093932223031444539194535584849593839[/DhtmlXQ_move_3_47_5] [DhtmlXQ_move_5_57_6]443430403231384849395859[/DhtmlXQ_move_5_57_6] [DhtmlXQ_move_5_49_7]44450201535250405242014142324050[/DhtmlXQ_move_5_49_7] [DhtmlXQ_move_1_27_8]62524041646306168646485863621626464426363938598962614131443489883839584852423637[/DhtmlXQ_move_1_27_8] [DhtmlXQ_move_8_35_9]4676263639385969383936377677585947695949[/DhtmlXQ_move_8_35_9] [DhtmlXQ_move_9_37_10]76775848775759496261494761514131524247455141313042324535[/DhtmlXQ_move_9_37_10] [DhtmlXQ_move_8_31_11]6362162662612636868141405251595561605535[/DhtmlXQ_move_8_31_11] [DhtmlXQ_move_0_24_12]7673864648586252733352424030656406166454162646432636394936374232373843453313545313195352193952420224453530403545403042413932454332124333384849395859[/DhtmlXQ_move_0_24_12] [DhtmlXQ_move_12_27_13]464373794353[/DhtmlXQ_move_12_27_13] [DhtmlXQ_move_0_19_14]802002526252404120257975254548584544754547254535254706166665162665642636394936376463354547253738635341314434384849395859[/DhtmlXQ_move_0_19_14] [DhtmlXQ_move_14_29_15]666558486564061664631626635326365343413144344535[/DhtmlXQ_move_14_29_15] [DhtmlXQ_move_14_28_16]753566650616656416266463263639493637635335454765373853434131433331413343413143333141[/DhtmlXQ_move_14_28_16] [DhtmlXQ_move_16_44_17]384849394546444858485242467633323130424176714131304032427179314140504252[/DhtmlXQ_move_16_44_17] [DhtmlXQ_move_14_24_18]0616254548584575797639491626757126367151586849593646476976746665[/DhtmlXQ_move_14_24_18] [DhtmlXQ_move_14_23_19]2024061647257976666576262547262724444858656416266454263654533637534341314333274752513130333230404441474539493738324245754121403042325848495938392141394941497535491935395141483832313931413130315958[/DhtmlXQ_move_14_23_19] [DhtmlXQ_move_19_47_20]3231477751414050313077703040704044403727403027373040[/DhtmlXQ_move_19_47_20] [DhtmlXQ_move_19_26_21]7977666577272427162627772636777836372547374765644737[/DhtmlXQ_move_19_26_21] [DhtmlXQ_move_21_29_22]2547162624444858656426366463363763534131394937474434474849395859[/DhtmlXQ_move_21_29_22] [DhtmlXQ_move_14_20_23]02035242405042320353325253526252[/DhtmlXQ_move_14_20_23] [DhtmlXQ_comment25]杨明忠先生诠注着法[/DhtmlXQ_comment25] [DhtmlXQ_comment37]和[/DhtmlXQ_comment37] [DhtmlXQ_comment1_25]各诠注本着法，黑胜[/DhtmlXQ_comment1_25] [DhtmlXQ_comment12_24]李浭先生诠注本着法[/DhtmlXQ_comment12_24] [DhtmlXQ_comment12_27]应走炮五进三拦炮可和[/DhtmlXQ_comment12_27] [DhtmlXQ_comment14_23]新着法[/DhtmlXQ_comment14_23] [DhtmlXQ_comment16_48]和棋[/DhtmlXQ_comment16_48] [DhtmlXQ_comment17_44]劣着[/DhtmlXQ_comment17_44] [DhtmlXQ_comment17_61]红胜[/DhtmlXQ_comment17_61] [DhtmlXQ_comment18_39]和棋[/DhtmlXQ_comment18_39] [DhtmlXQ_comment19_23]古谱着法，黑胜[/DhtmlXQ_comment19_23] [DhtmlXQ_refer]http%3A//www.dpxq.com/%0D%0Ahttp%3A//www.dpxq.com/hldcg/dhtmlxq/frame.htm[/DhtmlXQ_refer] [DhtmlXQ_generator]supersnow.ys168.com[/DhtmlXQ_generator] [/DhtmlXQ]

聨吟客

llllssss 发表于 2017-12-21 09:54
应该是和棋

看來此局紅和法還滿多種的,

chouzhouyu

最近打白宏宽周平所著的新书时，该书中的结论是黑胜。但感觉疑点很多，红方很多地方可以变招走和。


其它版本的百局象棋谱不在身边我还没有看。一楼贴中标注新招的是我的拆解，和诠注本的不一样。发现红方都可以走和。不知黑方在红方变招后有无再变招的地方可胜。

chouzhouyu

应该是和棋。各种诠注本中的黑胜结论其后续走法红方都可变招走和。